Were There German American Internment Camps? The Truth Behind the Myth

AvatarByDale Richard Camping

Were There German American Internment Camps?

The United States’ history of Japanese American internment during World War II is well-known, but did you know that German Americans were also subject to internment during the war? Although the number of German Americans interned was much smaller than the number of Japanese Americans, their experience is still an important part of American history.

In this article, we will explore the history of German American internment, from the early days of World War II to the eventual release of the internees. We will also discuss the lasting impact of German American internment on the United States.

By the end of this article, you will have a better understanding of this important chapter in American history.

Camp Name Location Number of Inmates
Crystal City Internment Camp Crystal City, Texas 7,433
Fort Missoula Internment Camp Fort Missoula, Montana 2,575
Fort Sibert Internment Camp Huntsville, Alabama 3,019
Fort Stanton Internment Camp Fort Stanton, New Mexico 1,498
Granada War Relocation Center Amache, Colorado 7,318
Jerome War Relocation Center Jerome, Arkansas 8,475
Manzanar War Relocation Center Manzanar, California 10,046
Minidoka War Relocation Center Hunt, Idaho 9,397
Poston War Relocation Center Poston, Arizona 17,814
Rohwer War Relocation Center Rohwer, Arkansas 8,475
Topaz War Relocation Center Topaz, Utah 8,130

History of German American Internment

Background on German Americans in the United States

German Americans are the largest ethnic group in the United States, with an estimated 46 million people claiming German ancestry. German immigrants began arriving in the United States in large numbers in the 18th century, and by the 19th century, German Americans were the largest ethnic group in the country. German Americans played a significant role in American history, and their contributions include the establishment of many major cities, such as Cincinnati, Milwaukee, and St. Louis.

Internment during World War I

During World War I, the United States government interned thousands of German Americans. The first wave of internments began in 1917, after the United States entered the war. At that time, the government feared that German Americans were a threat to national security and that they might engage in espionage or sabotage. The government also feared that German Americans would be sympathetic to Germany and would support the German war effort.

The first German Americans to be interned were aliens who were considered to be enemy aliens. Enemy aliens were people who were citizens of a country that was at war with the United States. They were subject to arrest and detention without trial. In addition to German aliens, the government also interned German Americans who were citizens of the United States. These citizens were interned because they were suspected of being disloyal to the United States.

The peak of German American internment occurred in 1918, when more than 6,000 German Americans were held in internment camps. The majority of these internees were held in camps in the western United States, such as Fort Sill, Oklahoma, and Fort Douglas, Utah.

The internment of German Americans during World War I was a controversial issue. Many people argued that the internments were unjustified and that they were based on prejudice and discrimination against German Americans. The internments also had a negative impact on the German American community, and they contributed to the decline of German culture in the United States.

Internment during World War II

During World War II, the United States government again interned thousands of German Americans. The first wave of internments began in 1941, after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. At that time, the government feared that Japanese Americans were a threat to national security and that they might engage in espionage or sabotage. The government also feared that Japanese Americans would be sympathetic to Japan and would support the Japanese war effort.

The first Japanese Americans to be interned were aliens who were considered to be enemy aliens. Enemy aliens were people who were citizens of a country that was at war with the United States. They were subject to arrest and detention without trial. In addition to Japanese aliens, the government also interned Japanese Americans who were citizens of the United States. These citizens were interned because they were suspected of being disloyal to the United States.

The peak of Japanese American internment occurred in 1942, when more than 110,000 Japanese Americans were held in internment camps. The majority of these internees were held in camps in the western United States, such as Manzanar, California, and Tule Lake, California.

The internment of Japanese Americans during World War II was a controversial issue. Many people argued that the internments were unjustified and that they were based on prejudice and discrimination against Japanese Americans. The internments also had a negative impact on the Japanese American community, and they contributed to the decline of Japanese culture in the United States.

Legality of German American Internment

Constitutional challenges to internment

The internment of German Americans during World War I and World War II was challenged on constitutional grounds. The main challenge was that the internments violated the Fifth Amendment, which prohibits the government from depriving people of their liberty without due process of law.

In the case of Korematsu v. United States (1944), the Supreme Court ruled that the internment of Japanese Americans was constitutional. The Court held that the government had a legitimate reason to intern Japanese Americans because of the threat of espionage and sabotage. The Court also held that the internments were necessary to protect national security.

The decision in Korematsu v. United States was controversial, and it has been criticized by many legal scholars. Critics argue that the decision was based on racial prejudice and that it violated the constitutional rights of Japanese Americans.

Executive orders authorizing internment

The internment of German Americans during World War I and World War II was authorized by executive orders issued by the President of the United States. The first executive order authorizing the internment of German Americans was issued by President Woodrow Wilson in 1917. The order authorized the Secretary of War to intern any alien who was considered to

Impact of German American Internment

The internment of German Americans had a significant impact on their social, economic, and political lives.

  • Social and economic impact

The internment of German Americans disrupted their lives and livelihoods. They were forced to leave their homes and businesses, and many lost their jobs and possessions. The internment also caused social isolation and discrimination against German Americans.

  • Psychological impact

The internment was a traumatic experience for many German Americans. They were subjected to harsh conditions and treated as criminals. The experience of being interned left many German Americans with feelings of anger, resentment, and distrust of the government.

  • Political impact

The internment of German Americans had a lasting impact on American politics. It raised questions about the government’s power to detain citizens without due process of law. The internment also contributed to the growth of the civil rights movement.

Legacy of German American Internment

The legacy of German American internment is complex and multifaceted. There are many different ways to remember and commemorate this event.

  • Memorials and museums

There are a number of memorials and museums dedicated to the memory of German American internees. These memorials and museums help to ensure that the history of internment is not forgotten.

  • Historical research

Historical research on German American internment is essential for understanding this event and its legacy. Historical research can help to shed light on the experiences of internees and the impact of internment on their lives.

  • Public discourse

Public discourse about German American internment is important for raising awareness of this event and its legacy. Public discourse can help to promote understanding and healing between different ethnic groups.

The internment of German Americans was a dark chapter in American history. It is important to remember this event and its legacy so that we can learn from the past and prevent similar injustices from happening again.

Q: Were There German American Internment Camps?

A: No, there were no German American internment camps in the United States during World War II. However, there were a number of Japanese American internment camps, as well as some Italian American internment camps.

Q: Why weren’t German Americans interned?

A: There are a number of reasons why German Americans were not interned during World War II. First, the United States was not at war with Germany until after the attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941. Second, German Americans were not seen as a threat to national security in the same way that Japanese Americans were. German Americans were largely assimilated into American society, and there was no widespread fear that they would engage in espionage or sabotage.

Q: What about German Americans who were suspected of being Nazis or sympathizers?

A: Some German Americans who were suspected of being Nazis or sympathizers were arrested and detained, but they were not held in internment camps. Instead, they were typically held in prisons or other federal facilities.

Q: What about German Americans who were drafted into the military?

A: German Americans who were drafted into the military were treated the same as any other American soldier. They were not discriminated against or singled out for special treatment.

Q: Why is it important to remember that there were no German American internment camps?

A: It is important to remember that there were no German American internment camps because it demonstrates that the United States did not engage in mass incarceration of its own citizens based on their ethnicity or national origin. This is a key part of our nation’s history, and it is important to remember it so that we can avoid repeating the mistakes of the past.

there were no German American internment camps in the United States during World War II. While some German Americans were arrested and detained, they were not held in camps specifically for German Americans. Instead, they were held in the same camps as other enemy aliens, including Italians, Japanese, and Japanese Americans. The experience of German Americans during World War II is a reminder of the importance of civil liberties and due process of law, even during times of war.

Author Profile

Dale Richard
Dale Richard
Dale, in his mid-thirties, embodies the spirit of adventure and the love for the great outdoors. With a background in environmental science and a heart that beats for exploring the unexplored, Dale has hiked through the lush trails of the Appalachian Mountains, camped under the starlit skies of the Mojave Desert, and kayaked through the serene waters of the Great Lakes.

His adventures are not just about conquering new terrains but also about embracing the ethos of sustainable and responsible travel. Dale’s experiences, from navigating through dense forests to scaling remote peaks, bring a rich tapestry of stories, insights, and practical tips to our blog.